Just came back from a great meeting with my director. This was the first time in a very long time that I've worked with a director who is that prepared. He had great specific notes on the script, and we had a lengthy discussion about the middle section of the play.
What was interesting about today's meeting was that the director knew something was wrong with the middle, but didn't know how to state the problem and proposed a solution instead. It seems to be human nature that people want to talk about solutions rather than problems in scripts, but everyone forgets that the writer is the one who has to go back to solve the problem, and if they don't understand what isn't working, then the solution will never fully work.
Today, I challenged the director to get specific about his concerns. When we talked further about his concerns, we found out that we had different ideas about what Norman was trying to do in the middle section. He wanted Norman to be out of control of his ideas so that it would be different from the first third of the play. In short, he felt like the middle didn't have higher stakes than the first section and felt a bit flat. It took a few minutes of conversation to get to that specific problem, but it was well worth the time, because once I zeroed in on the problem, I could offer a solution to fix it that I could actually get behind.
I encourage all budding writers to take the time to challenge notes and find out the root of the problem. There's the danger of looking defensive, but as long as the writer is willing to find the problem and solve it and leave ego out of the equation, then everything should be fine. My point is that anyone who gives notes should be able to back up their thoughts with something specific, so that the writer can react to it. I was so happy that my director came to the meeting prepared, because we could actually discuss the play on a deeper level and find the problem. I can't count the number of times that I've found a director hasn't done his homework, and delivers notes off the cuff and without much forethought.
Anyway, this meeting gives me great trust in my director, and I can't wait to jump into the play and make the revisions that we agreed on.